QUOTE(Exon @ Dec 11 2009, 01:04 AM)
Romesh,
You have put a lot of effort in assembling this spreadsheet. All members will benefit from your spreadsheet.
Thanks a lot.
In a few instances, your spreadsheet data and my tags (or info) have mismatch.
Kashmir Ki Kali (1946):
+ yeh kisne meri hasraton mein aag laga di - GD
Chanda Ki Chandni (1948) :
- kaali kaali raat hai, par saas teri sojaaye toh kuch baat hai - Sulochana Kadam?, Hussain:
Chandralekha (1948):
+ mat ga mat gaa re,yeh sher bachhe -GD, Rafi, chorus
Chunaria (1948):
Phool toh Phool & tera kaanton se hain pyaar
(I think, these 2 are one and same song)
Dilruba 1948 > 1950?
Mala the Mighty (1948):
+ kaun hai jispe zamane ne sitam dhaya nahin - GD
Padmini (1948):
+ tum hi na sunoge toh meri kaun sunega - GD
Dil Ki Basti (1949):
+ jal jal ke kahein hum - GD
Sunhere Din (1949):
+ umangon ke din beete jaayen ... haaye jawaani kase lagaa le - (Film ver) GD, Surinder Kaur, Sjamshad Begum
Baabul (1950):
- milte hi aankhen (version song) - Hemant Kumar, Rama Devi?
Jalte Deep (1950):
+ taaron bhari raat mein yaad tumhari aaye baalam - GD
Kanch Ki Gudiya (1961):
+ koyi bachaa lo mujhko bacha lo - GD
Shama (1961)
shaguftagi ka latafat -Geeta Dutt?
Exon
dear exon
First of all I must convey my thanks for having a detailed glance at the effort made by me. I would like to point out that as already brought out in my original post the basic spreadsheet of the database was downloaded from the web site geetadutt.com. I have only added the missing songs in bold letters after consulting the GEETKOSH. I have not touched the information already provided on the spreadsheet. However,at one or two places I had made corrections as per Geet Kosh.
Now coming to the queries raised by you the information is as under
KASHMIR KI KALI-1946-- The missing song mentioned by you is already there in the spread sheet. There is a mention of this film 1n the year 1947 also which need to be deleted.
CHANDA KI CHANDNI-1948-- There is no mention of sulochana kadam as co singer in the spread sheet
CHANDERLEKHA-1948--In the geet kosh it has been mentioned as a chorus. In case ur tagging is correct this song needs to be mentioned in the data sheet.I am not capable of giving any comment on this
CHUNARIYA-1948--Your observation is correct one of the songs needs to deleted (these two songs were there in the original data base)
DILRUBA-1950 This is 1950 film and not 1948
MALA THE MIGHTY-1948 N o information in the geet kosh. In the event of ur tagging being correct. this song needs to be added in the data base
PADMINI-1948 No mention in the geet kosh I ncase ur tagging is correct this needs to be added in the data base
DIL KI BASTI-1949 My mistake this song is there in the geet kosh but inadvertently i missed it to mention in the database
SUNEHRE DIN-1949--No comments since I have not seen the film
BAABUL-1950No comments on this since there is no mention of this song in the geet kosh
JALTE DEEP-1950--This song has been mentioned in the database
KANCH KI GUDIYA-1961--My mistake this song is there in the geet kosh, inadvertently missed it.Needs to be mentioned in the database
SHAMA-1961--This song has been mentioned in the data base
There are non filmi songs sung by geetaji in my collection which needs to be mentioned in the data base.The list of these songs is being u/l separately
with best wishes
romesh