Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Suchitra Sen And Geeta Dutt
Hamara Forums > Legends > Geeta Dutt
parag_sankla
http://stationhollywood.blogspot.com/2008/...geeta-dutt.html

Suchitra Sen and Geeta Dutt.


Suchitra Sen had a tremendous combination with singer Geeta Dutt and their understanding both in Bengali films and bollywood films had created history during the golden age, that is the 50s and 60s. In the film Indrani, all the songs sung by Geeta Dutt for Suchitra Sen including “jhanak jhanak madhur badan”, “nir choto khoti nei”, “ogo sundoro”, etc., all became super hit. Suchitra Sen provided hit films one after the other with Uttam Kumar, during that age and Indrani also falls in that category.

Even in films where Geeta Dutt had sung only one song for Suchitra Sen, even in those films, the songs had a great impact in the success of the films. The song in the Ajoy Kar’s epic film Harano Sur, in 1957, titled “tumi je amar” had a unique appeal for the audience. Uttam Kumar lost his memory due to meeting with an accident and Suchitra Sen sang the song a number of times in the film. It haunted the viewers and touched the souls of numerous admirers of Bengali films.

Geeta Dutt’s song for Suchitra Sen also in the film Hospital also became extremely successful. Ashok Kumar acted opposite Suchitra Sen in the film and the song was “ei shundar sharnali sondhae”.

In bollywood films, SD Burman used Geeta Dutt for Suchitra Sen in the film Bombai Ka Babu. Dev Anand acted opposite Suchitra Sen in the film and all the songs were super hits. The main songs included “dekhne me bhola hai”, “pa ma ga”, etc., out of which some of them were duet songs with Mohammad Rafi and their romantic by every musical standard.

As Suchitra Sen made memorable contribution in bollywood films for more than 30 years, a lot of legendary singers contributed for her during that period. There were hit songs sung by Sandhya Mukherjee in landmark films like Sagarika, Pathe Holo Deri, Sriti Tuku Thak, Uttar Falguni, Bipasha, etc. At the same time in bollywood films Lata had sung landmark songs for Suchitra Sen including “rahe na rahe hum” composed by Roshan in the film Mamta, “is mor se jate hai”, “tere bina zindagi me shikwa” composed by RD Burman in the film Aandhi.

Even then Geeta Dutt was probably the only singer who sang songs for Suchitra Sen both in the Bengali films as well as the bollywood films. As Suchitra Sen’s hindi films were restricted to only Devdas, Champakali, Musafir, Bombai Ka Babu, Mamta, Aandhi, etc, Geeta Dutt got a limited scope of contributing in Suchitra Sen’s hindi films. Even then, the songs are still remembered by many generations and for those reasons the films should also be preserved.

parag_sankla
Just one small correction to the blog :

It was Asha ji (and not Geeta ji) who sang the songs of Bambai ka baabu. So AFAIK, Geeta ji has not sung for Suchitra Sen for Hindi films.

Subject to correction!
parag_sankla
I know for sure that Geeta ji sang for Mala Sinha in Bengali as well as Hindi films. May be Nepali too ?? (Maitighar)
parag_sankla
QUOTE(parag_sankla @ Dec 16 2008, 06:15 AM) *

Just one small correction to the blog :

It was Asha ji (and not Geeta ji) who sang the songs of Bambai ka baabu. So AFAIK, Geeta ji has not sung for Suchitra Sen for Hindi films.

Subject to correction!


Can some one please confirm this ?

Thanks
Parag
abhayp
QUOTE(parag_sankla @ Jan 10 2009, 06:39 PM) *

QUOTE(parag_sankla @ Dec 16 2008, 06:15 AM) *

Just one small correction to the blog :

It was Asha ji (and not Geeta ji) who sang the songs of Bambai ka baabu. So AFAIK, Geeta ji has not sung for Suchitra Sen for Hindi films.

Subject to correction!


Can some one please confirm this ?

Thanks
Parag


Suchitra Sen acted in seven Hindi films (listed in chronological order): Devdas, Musafir, Champakali, Bambai Ka Babu, Sarhad, Mamta, and Aandhi. It's fairly easy to track her playback singers in each of them:

1. Devdas - AFAIR, there is no song picturised on her (in any case, the two Geeta Dutt songs in the film are picturised on Dulari).

2. Musafir - I don't remember whether she has a song picturised on her but, since there is no Geeta song in that film, the question is irrelevant here.

3. Champakali - Lata Mangeshkar.

4. Bambai Ka Babu - Asha Bhosle.

5. Sarhad - Asha Bhosle.

6. Mamta - Lata Mangeshkar, Asha Bhosle, Suman Kalyanpur.

7. Aandhi - Lata Mangeshkar.

Unless someone comes up with an additional Hindi film starring Suchitra Sen (*and* having Geeta Dutt as playback singer), we can take if for granted that your hypothesis is correct.

Warm regards,
Abhay
parag_sankla
Yes Abhay, your analysis seems to be correct. So Geeta ji only sang in Bengali films for Suchitra Sen.

Thanks for the clarification

Best Regards
Parag
chowdhury
QUOTE(parag_sankla @ Jan 11 2009, 01:48 AM) *

Yes Abhay, your analysis seems to be correct. So Geeta ji only sang in Bengali films for Suchitra Sen.

Thanks for the clarification

Best Regards
Parag



Hi I have a query did Geeta Dutta sing the song ' Nupurer O Gunjane' from Bengali film Shilpi?
hildebrand
QUOTE(chowdhury @ Jun 13 2009, 12:05 PM) *

QUOTE(parag_sankla @ Jan 11 2009, 01:48 AM) *

Yes Abhay, your analysis seems to be correct. So Geeta ji only sang in Bengali films for Suchitra Sen.

Thanks for the clarification

Best Regards
Parag



Hi I have a query did Geeta Dutta sing the song ' Nupurer O Gunjane' from Bengali film Shilpi?


On listening it appears to be a Sandhya Mukherjee song.

Here's the youtube link to the song for the experts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vq-1QbPOdOc
RajanCS
Maheshji had clarifed this in past as a Sandhya Mukherjee song.



QUOTE(smahesh @ Feb 1 2009, 03:20 PM) *

QUOTE(RajanCS @ Feb 1 2009, 02:24 PM) *

Parag,

I am uploading the song. However, I had doubt whether credentials mentioned against it were correct. Reason for the doubt was because the singer appeared to have had a formal classical training whereas, ASAIK, Geeta ji did not have a formal classical training. If I am wrong in my presumption, please correct me. Please listen to it and let me know:

Nupurer Gunjone
Film: Shilpi (Bangla)
Bitrate: 192 kbps
Duration: 00:03:20

Click to view attachment

Regards,

Rajan

rajanji,
the singer is sandhya mukherji.
regards,
mahesh
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.