Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Anyone Has It?
Hamara Forums > Music > Regional Music > Tamil
Nimii
If anyone has this please share..

Inthru vanda sondama.. idayil vanda bandama.. innum pala janamame... (by P Susheela and TMS I think)

I have this song in hindi - a LM/Talat Mahmood duet.

N
sangeetbhakt
QUOTE(Nimii @ Apr 9 2006, 10:46 AM) *

If anyone has this please share..

Inthru vanda sondama.. idayil vanda bandama.. innum pala janamame... (by P Susheela and TMS I think)

I have this song in hindi - a LM/Talat Mahmood duet.

N

Here you go. The Tamil copy of "Yeh nayi nayi preet hai" from the
ultimate copy-cat music composer Veda. The film is "Chitrangi".
Nimii
hhahaha SB Ji purrfect naam diya COPY_CAT !!!!!!!!!!!!!! blab.gif Priyz is not here to defend the cat parivaar biggrin.gif

So many nos. he has copied mad.gif sigh!!!!!!!!!!! Originality ka ata pata hi nahi hai sad1.gif

Thankoooooooooooooo SB ji bow.gif
bawlachintu
QUOTE(sangeetbhakt @ Apr 10 2006, 11:55 AM) *

QUOTE(Nimii @ Apr 9 2006, 10:46 AM) *

If anyone has this please share..

Inthru vanda sondama.. idayil vanda bandama.. innum pala janamame... (by P Susheela and TMS I think)

I have this song in hindi - a LM/Talat Mahmood duet.

N

Here you go. The Tamil copy of "Yeh nayi nayi preet hai" from the
ultimate copy-cat music composer Veda. The film is "Chitrangi".

Thanks. Rearrange the spelling of Veda and u will
find the name of another copy-cat wink.gif
Nimii
Deva copies too shocked.gif mad.gif

sri
QUOTE(sangeetbhakt @ Apr 10 2006, 11:55 AM) *
Here you go. The Tamil copy of "Yeh nayi nayi preet hai" from the
ultimate copy-cat music composer Veda. The film is "Chitrangi".

Well....the ultimate copy-cat (as you say), did not copy entirely mindlessly !!

Ths song is actually a blend of 2 songs !!

It starts with the Pocketmaar song...then the interlude music - also from the Pocketmaar song...but the verse is lifted from 'Na tum hamen jaano' from Baat ek raat ki. Thereafter, there's a short piece inspired from the Pocketmaar verse ...and then the song returns to the mukhda of the Pocketmaar song !!

In 50s and 60s, there were many 'exchanges' between Tamil and Hindi films....from the time of C Ramchandra ( who in fact started his career with Tamil films). Most of these were triggered by the same producer making a Hindi and a Tamil version...and good songs / scene -specific songs were often reproduced in the later version. But the music directors would be different since only one or two tunes may have been retained...and the rest would still have to be composed afresh. Therefore, the music directors of such films cannot be held to have 'copied' these tunes...since these must have been decided by the producer / director - possibly in consultation with the music director. We have seen such songs being repeated in Hindi films too where the composer of the corresponding Tamil song is mentioned in the credits of the film...as music consultant or associate .....but not as music director.

In this case, however, the producers of the two films in question ( pocketmaar 1956 and chitrangi 1964) do not appear to be the same...and it is possible that the copy-cat title may be appropriate - esp in the context where the song is based on 2 entirely different songs - one of Madan Mohan (1956) and one of S D Burman (1962) !!

Sri
Nimii
ohmy.gif Is that so Sriji!!

Vaise I havent heard Deva's that many songs sad1.gif
bawlachintu
Deva is known to have produced South Indian
version of

Jaana o meri jaana-Sanam teri kasam-Kamal Hasan-RDB

Prabhudeva featured in South Indian movie as hero.
Nimii
Did he BC ji.. never heard it tho' sigh.gif
bawlachintu
QUOTE(Nimii @ Apr 17 2006, 02:04 PM) *

Did he BC ji.. never heard it tho' sigh.gif

Maine to dekha bhi hai. Ek din galti se SUN TV dekh liya tha wink.gif

Deva ji par kuchh aur masala idhar hai:

http://www.tfmpage.com/copied/

Dr Alban Backstreet boys, sabhi kuchh pasand hai apne Deva ko biggrin.gif
Nimii
All new new movies na isiliye main nahi jaanti cry.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2021 Invision Power Services, Inc.