As I promised elsewhere, here is a post which collects different rendition of "Ranjish hee sahi" by different singers.

So far I have seen them sung by the quintessentially romantic Mehdi Hasan saaheb, Runa Laila who sang it a shade close to perfection too like MH, and Iqbal Bano.

I have uploaded Runa's version before. Let me collect all the links here:

Runa Laila: http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?act=...e=post&id=21164

Mehdi Hasan: uploaded here

I am uploading Iqbal Bano's version here.

Feel free to post or discuss any other renditions here..


ranjish hii sahii dil hii dukhaane ke liye aa
aa phir se mujhe chho.D ke jaane ke liye aa

pahale se maraasim na sahii phir bhii kabhii to
rasm-o-rahe duniyaa hii niibhaane ke liye aa

anurag

It seems there are renditions of this ghazal by Farida Khanum, Talat Aziz, and Anuradha Podwal as well. This must be the most sung ghazal in the history of ghazal singing (or am I exaggerating?)...

The ghazal has been sung by most based on raga yaman - an evening raga and that may be a good reason why it feels good to hear it after a day's work lounging on the couch sipping a cup of coffee.

anurag

There is Hari Haran version of this song too. Kuch Saal pehele MTV mein chagaya tha. Another lovely ghazal that was on air during those days...

Sham Se Aankh Mein Nami Si Hai..

lovely picturization.. kind of sad. This guy who is sitting in the office.. his eyes happens to fall on his wife's photo. Then the scene is taken when they first met etc.. but later.. she died in an accident.

The lyrics available here: http://www.geocities.com/sid_rsingh/jmshaam.htm

Shaam se aankh mein nami si hai
aaj phir aapki kami si hai

Dafan kardo hume ke saans mile
nabz kuch der se thami si hai

Waqt rukta nahin kahin tik kar
iski aadat bhi aadmi si hai

Koi rishta nahin raha phir bhi
ek tasleem bhi lazmi si hai

Anyone having HariHaran's or Talat Aziz's version?

Chitra, AFAIK, Jaggu dada never sang Ranjish hee sahi!!!! If you have that ghazal then it's a miracle and you are blessed. Can you please post it?

anurag

I see, Chitra. No problem. I should have noticed that you had Pradeep's post in quote.

We still need renditions by Talat Aziz, Anuradha Podwal, Farida khanum and Hariharan to make this thread complete...

where are all ghazal listeners - extenok, nadeem, rom, shuklas and others? I am a young and unyielding animal - don't test my patience, you guys.

Pradeep, I was n't sure if you wanted Jaggu's version or Asha's but here it is Jagjit singh's version anyway..It's from marasim.

Wow.. so fast. Thanks buddy

Here's AB version.

Infact this ghazal shaam se aankh mein written by Gulzar is also sung by Mukesh for a shelved film MITTI KA DEV composed by Salil(Asha version composed by RD,Jagjit version composed by Jagjit himself)
Abbasi

Hi folks

Ek aur hai Patta Patta Boota Boota

jis par bahut saaron ne khujaal nikali hai.

I think, first one was Mehndi Hasan, then
Ek nazar film, uske baad Jaggu ji ne.
Four versions of this song/????? are
available.

Highlights of 1000MW from Ghazal/nazm fans please.



chintu