QUOTE(hits @ Aug 23 2005, 08:18 AM)
QUOTE(Pradeep @ Aug 22 2005, 11:37 PM)
I agree with you hits. NDTV gets skilled people to chat up with politicians, but use *babes* as news readers and to chat up with personalities or topics they consider not so important.
Absolutely. The same goes for other channels too. My significant other used to be a reporter for Zee, New Delhi, and tells me horror stories of how editors mercilessly edit out material in such interviews in order to make them fit their pre-conceived notions. She actually knows this "babe" and was quite amused by the fact that she was interviewing Asha.
I just finished watching this "interview" and I must say it is a travesty. Can we write to NDTV to complain about what a deplorable job they did??
The interviewer woman was both rude (she kept speaking over Asha ji) and ignorant (she had no clue what Asha was talking about). At one point she tells Asha that "OPNayyar gave your voice swing while RDB challenged it"!! Talk about propagating stereotypes!
And why is this interview titled "Chhoti si Asha" again??? There is nothing "chhoti" about a singer of her caliber. May be they were trying to take off on the song from Roja that had this name. Someone should tell them the song was sung by Minmini, not Ashaji! It is ridiculous to title an interview with Asha Bhonsle based on a song of relatively little importance that she didnot even sing!
Anyway, enough ranting from me. I do wish someone would do a Shekar Gupta style interview with Asha where the interviewer can ask her some solid questions and actually get some insights into her life, work, and the HFM industry in general. I for one would like to know
- whether she harbors any resentment against her family for the early troubles in her married life
- what she thinks about all those singers whose careers did not take off allegedly due to the "Mangeshkar monopoly", people like Sharda, Suman K., Vani Jayaram, and the like
- what she thinks about age and how it has changed her as a singer-- how has her voice and range have changed, for example
- whether she has any regrets in her career, anything she feels she should have done when her voice was at its prime
- collaborations with western artists, why she did them and what she learnt from them. Does she regret not having gotten more intl. exposure to date (i remember reading somewhere that she regrets not being able to sing opera when she was younger)
- questions about her associations with great MDs like Ravi, S-J, K-A, Jaidev
- her ghazal obsession, why she does a ghazal album every few years and which one she cherishes the most (Meraj-e-ghazal, Aabshaar-e-ghazal, Kashish,...)
Basically something that goes beyond the obvious cliches we hear all the time and actually gives a candid picture of the woman, her life, and her work. Also, get her to sing more!! She has such a lovely voice that sounds so different on an ordinary vox recorder (as opposed to dynamic microphones in a studio).
Does anyone have the "itni gustaakh na ho ishq ki aawaara nazar" track that she hums in the interview? Apparently composed by Khaiyaam in his first film Lala Rukh(?).
-manoneet