[quote=the_cotton_cloud,May 17 2005, 03:57 AM]
thanx US rafian ji
by the way, there was an anecdote about Roshan Sahab which I had read somewhere which talked of Roshan Sb having requested SD about borrowing the tune from one of his songs. Roshan Sb then made a few cosmetic changes to the original. The song, like its original became a huge hit.
But the story doesnt end here. The tune was again remodified and reused, this time by RD for his own version.
The three songs in chronological order are
Thandi hawayen (SD)
Rahen na rahen hum (Roshan)
Sagar Kinare (RD)
In my opinion, a close comparison of these songs reveals the supremacy of both SD and Roshan over RD. The fact that RD never went beyond FIVE swars for composing his songs (which ofcourse led to him being called Pancham) is apparent as his version doesnt have the depth and the range of swars that are present in the two superior versions. This also redeems the belief that 50s and 60s were indeed the GOLDEN ERA of Hindi Music, and that this was made possible by not only by the singers like the Great Rafi Sahab, Manna Da, Mukesh Sahab, Latabai, Ashaji, Geetaji, Talat Sahab, but also the music directors such as Roshan Sahab. The quality was compromised to a huge extent from the 70s onwards, in order to adapt to the western tunes, disregarding the Indian ragas and triggering a gradual decline in the greatness of the output
Hope the real music lives on till the end of time
Tanvir
[/quote]
Dear Tanvir,
First, pl. accept my thankx for rebrushing my memory by refering the songs.
'Thandi..' & 'Rahen..' are definately clones & see the miracle that both are individual in its own place & both are immortals (uffffff!!!).
As for as 'Sagar Kinare..' by RD Sahab, is a tribute to Madan Mohan by RD sahab himself. The orignal song on the same tune was ...
'Yehi Hai Tamanna,
Tere Ghar Ke Saamne,
Meri Jaan Jaaye,
Meri Jaan Jaaye
Haaye '
The tune itself hunted RD Sahab & comes out in this way..
[compare above tune with ...
Saagar Kinaare,
Dil Ye Pukaare,
Tu Jo Nahi To Mera,
Koii Nahin Hay,
Haaye ]
[The above is just our love to great compositions]
By the way, Greats are having great ways of appreciation.
[/quote]
This also redeems the belief that 50s and 60s were indeed the GOLDEN ERA of Hindi Music, and that this was made possible by not only by the singers like the Great Rafi Sahab, Manna Da, Mukesh Sahab, Latabai, Ashaji, Geetaji, Talat Sahab, but also the music directors such as Roshan Sahab.
[/quote]
YES, very much TRUE
[/quote]
The quality was compromised to a huge extent from the 70s onwards, in order to adapt to the western tunes, disregarding the Indian ragas and triggering a gradual decline in the greatness of the output
[/quote]
Without dedication, true gem will never come out. It is painful that the current era has insisted the generation to become millionaire in overnight. Hardship, Dedication, Love (diwaangi ki haddd tak) are the things of past.
[/quote]
Hope the real music lives on till the end of time
[/quote]
GOD BLESS YOU DEAR