QUOTE(Faraaj73 @ Aug 29 2008, 02:57 PM)

QUOTE(r&d @ Aug 30 2008, 04:42 AM)

Takra gaya (Version Song) - Hemant Kumar - Aan (1952) - Naushad - Shakeel Badayuni - 3:21 - 64 kbps
Mera Jeevan Sathi Bichud Gaya (Version Song) - Hemant Kumar - Babul (1950) - Naushad - Shakeel Badayuni - 3:20 - 64 kbps
Thanks for these uploads. Interesting!
Mera Jeevan Saathi is well sung but in Takra Gaya Tumse the special chemistry that Rafi-Naushad shared is completely missing. If Hemant had sung the song in the film, it would not have been so successful.
Kind Regards
Faraaj
Version songs were recorded after a song becomes a super hit and
HMV wants to make more money of it. There is no question that
Naushad was going to use only Rafi's version. I mean Dillip Kumar is
the star and Hemant Kumar was not going to sing for Dillip.
So this speculation is quite out of place.