comments: While the casting of MALAMAAL WEEKLY is perfect, it's the script that lets Priyadarshan down this time. Of course, Priyadarshan's earlier films also defied logic and the emphasis was on non-stop entertainment, but MALAMAAL WEEKLY has too many tracks running parallel with the main plot and the outcome isn't as stimulating as the accomplished director's earlier works.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In a nutshell, MALAMAAL WEEKLY isn't great cinema. Nor is it a terrible letdown. It floats in between, a strictly average fare with the by-now-famous Priyadarshan touch visible sporadically and intermittently.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As the director of MALAMAAL WEEKLY, Priyadarshan isn't in complete form either. Erratic writing takes a toll on the product and you feel that the film bears an uncanny resemblance to HERA PHERI especially. Even if you compare it with Priyadarshan's earlier works, MALAMAAL WEEKLY is a step down.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music -- there's just one song in the film [filmed on Raakhi Sawant] -- and it's strictly okay. Cinematography [Sameer Arya] is of standard. Dialogues are the highpoint of the enterprise. In fact, a few one-liners have the required punch to create the desired impact. Editing is loose. The film can easily be trimmed by 15-20 minutes.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Paresh Rawal gets a meaty role in every Priyadarshan film and MALAMAAL WEEKLY is no exception. Paresh delivers a performance that is bound to be talked-about in days to come. He is in terrific form. Om Puri plays to the gallery with flourish, thereby proving his versatility yet again. Ritesh doesn't get much scope, but proves his mettle in the engagement sequence. Reema Sen doesn't get scope at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Asrani is excellent. He gets the maximum footage after Paresh and Om and it's indeed a pleasure to watch the veteran in great form. Rajpal Yadav is efficient. Sudha Chandran enacts her part with conviction. Shakti Kapoor gets limited scope. Rasika Joshi is perfect. Malayalam actor Innocent is fair. Arbaaz Khan [sp. app.] leaves a mark.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maalamaal Weekly is a bizarre enlivening of one of those Tinkle comic stories set in a bucolic background – buffaloes, picturesque poverty, turbaned men in clothes with vibrantly contrasting patches, elementary plots and recycled jokes. The comedy is woefully childish, something you learn within the first frame itself.
Yet the rustic characters, their crude, idiomatic talk, just their perfectly dirty clothes and
langotis, the way they sit on their haunches and feed leaves to their goats – all that imagery keeps you hooked for a while. You can almost smell the unwashed sweat mixed with the scent of cow-dung covered courtyards. Which is an odd digression in a comedy movie. Which is why I say MW is bizarre. Crazy. Kooky!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maalamaal Weekly is ultimately an unfortunate waste of costume and set planning, and so many brilliant actors. It makes you feel that Priyadarshan needn’t have taken the trouble. A comedy is much simpler ‘cause its trigger is purely cerebral. More authentic characters or a snake-pit of a plot isn’t going to make anyone laugh harder. Just a genuinely funnier joke instead of the labyrinthine chases would have had the audience in raptures
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MalamaalWeekly seems to be a ripoff of the English movie "Waking Ned Devine". It's a shame PriyaDarshan is making a fool of people by trying to steal ideas and then passing off as original. In a field bereft of originality, there is nothing wrong in seeking "inspiration" or remaking good plots in a different language. But, parading it is as one's own idea, in this age of internet and cable (where movies are easily accessible) is foolishness.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have been a big fan of Priydarshan's movies! Sorry to say this, but did you say this story of Malamal Weekly is yours Mr. Priyadarshan? Have you heard of the movie 'Waking Ned Divine'? I belive its a movie from Ireland which was a success in 1998! Your story seems to be very similar to that one! Ofcourse without the Bollywood additons... So what do you have to say?
Own it Priyan!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
He is fantastic Director and what I like more abt him is that he excepts if the story is a copy unlike others. There was a time in Malayalam Movies with high quality comedy and priyan is trying to get the same glory for hindi viewers by remaking them.
Very Good Luck For the Director.