QUOTE(hits @ Jun 25 2005, 07:11 PM)
QUOTE(urzung khan @ Jun 24 2005, 05:35 PM)
QUOTE(hits @ Jun 24 2005, 05:33 AM)
All the songs you have uploaded (1 to 9, except 5 & 6) have Shamshad Beghum as the primary singer. The only other voices are attributable to "Chorus". Songs 5 and 6 have music director Ghulam Haider's voice also.
'peene ke din aaye' was sung by Umrao Zia Begum.
Are you sure that Inaam has uploaded Zia Beghum's version, urzung? The reason I ask is that this movie had soundtrack issued under 2 labels - Columbia and another that I forget. Now, this second label has been out of circulation since the late 40s, to my knowledge, and that included some of the songs in Zia Beghum's voice. However, the more commonly available records have included the "Peene Ke Din Aaye" song in Shamshad Beghum's voice, I believe.
I'm sure you would have a better idea than me, on whether the uploaded song actually sounds like Shamshad or Zia.
I was interested in the three songs which I requested Mr Inaam to ul.
So I had not dld pkda. Now I have and played it. It is not in Shamshad's
voice. I have two copies of pkda, one dating back to sixties and another
dated 2004, obtained from different sources, both are in the voice of
Umrao Zia Begum. The second one was sourced from video.
You have spoken about version records. This needs further investigation.
Was the second lable ' Jeinophone' ?