QUOTE
vasu_m_r Posted Today, 10:08 AM
QUOTE(Bawra Jay @ Apr 7 2005, 08:41 PM)
QUOTE(vasu_m_r @ Apr 7 2005, 08:25 AM)
3) Woh jo hum me tum mein qarar tha - ( a live version in which he started with Ka karoo Sajani, other wil also do )
Hi Vasu , looking at the way you have requested for specifically a live version in which he starts.... with ka karoon sajni .... made me curious.... where and when did u hear it first... Are u a big fan of Ghulam Ali ... or any particular singer... or just GHAZALS , etc....
By any chance you from USA ... Ghulam Ali ji along with Talat Sahab is doing good concerts across many states in USA.. just in case if you are interested.....
Why to settle for less (other will also do...... ) ..... here is the exact same version of your request... Its a live version where he starts with Ka karoon sajni..... ENJOY
I have the rest of all from the list as well but they all ripped at much higher bitrate and are above 15 - 20 MB , so give me sometime (remind me if I forget) .... and would upload it.... or if anyone else wanna jump in and do the needful .....
I have this on an audio tape. I am a very big fan of Ghulam Ali and a big fan of ghazals in general. I am in Chennai which is possibly the last place where there will be a live concert of Ghulam Ali. I prefer Ghulam Ali since in his singing, the words are generally very very clear unlike say Jagit Singh. I also have a partiality for male ghazal singers (horrible Male Chauvinist Pig I guess) since I believe that male voices convey a lot more depth (only if they are good ofcourse !) Not that I dislike women singers but given a choice between say Begum Akhtar or Ghulam Ali I would prefer Ghulam Ali.
vasu bro u made comparision between BEGUM AKHTAR and GHULAM ALI
both of them have no comparision BEGUM is known for her traditional GAZAL ANDAAZ along with NAAT,DAADRI and THUMRI

where as GHULAM ALI is known for his new outlook for GAZAL along with semi-classical GAZAL folk PUNJABI songs.
have u heard the above GAZAL in BEGUM voice ?
"woh jo humein tumein"
its 8th april 2005 till date i guess she sang it mostly beautifully then any1 else.
i have heard this GAZAL in the voice of BEGUM AKHTAR,GHULAM ALI,PARVEEN SULTANA and CHITRA SINGH.
i would vote BEGUM SAHIBA above all just feel her pain when she says "WOH NAAYE GEELE WOH SHIKAYATE"
more over she laid the foundation stone of GAZAL GAYEKI i meant a professional GAZAL SINGER.though there was KL SAIGAL and few more but SAIGAL was more inclined to movies.
few days before she demised she sang a GAZAL which says
"SUNA KARO MIAYAN UNSE UNKE AAFSAANE,SABHI AJNABI HAI YAHAN KAUN KISI PEHCHANE"so true
if any1 has this GAZAL plz ul