Tarannum Ka Safar, 1939 to 1999, Year by Year Options

[Inaam]

Dear Noor Jehan Fans!
Madam Noor Jehan reigned supreme over the South Asian music scene for more than six decades. On the occasion of her 5th death anniversary, I would like to post a glossy overview of her work as a singer. In this thread, I will mention the best songs of each year from 1939 to 1999 (60 years) and will share a song from each year as song of the year. I request you all to participate in the discussion and share your comments.

1939
Best of the year:
Shala Jawaniyan Mane (Gul-e-Bakwali)
Pinjre Wich Qaid Jawani (Gul-e-Bakwali)
Ek Sohne Jae Jungle Wich (Gul-e-Bakwali)

Song of the Year:
Shala Jawaniyan Mane (Gul-e-Bakwali)

[surhall]

Ummer, you are correct. I agree with your statement and appreciate your hard work. I hope Dhal Sahib ki ghalat fehmi door ho gai hogi.?

Sorry I an not agree. till from my side right.

dhall

[Ummer]

Hello Dhall Sahib,

I know you since the days of SKS yahoo groups. It is almost 8 years now. As far as I remember or have known you, you haven't made any contribution to any forums from your OWN collection. All you do is either cut and paste from different websites and/or what other members upload, you download that stuff and then upload it in some other thread.

I remember many incidents like this. On RMIM groups you posted an article on Swaranlata which was written by me and copied it from website. Also there was another incident on RMIM, where you copied something from my website and kept on saying you have newspaper cutting of it and some esteemed member of RMIM proved it that you were lying. Also, Mahesh posted some Shamshad songs and you downloaded them and posted it in some other thread the SAME day without giving credit to the original contributor. I don't know why you do this but it makes you less trustworthy in other people eyes and people don't trust you anymore.

Anyways, coming back to the original topic. If your Mamu is that old, it might be possible that memories are playing hide and seek with him. Your only proof that Noor Jehan starred in those movies is that your Mamu said so... right?

I am willing to bet $100 infront of all members if you prove it to me that Noor Jehan (the actress-singer) starred in Abidah and Meera Bai. Long time ago, a rare interview was published in some newspaper in which W.Z. Ahmed discussed his films in detail and he said, the favorite film of his career was Meera Bai. There was NO Noor Jehan in that film.

If you think Noor Jehan starred in those films, show me a reasonable proof? Film Print, Picture or some article?

Thanks,

Ummer.

[surhall]

Hello Dhall Sahib,

I know you since the days of SKS yahoo groups. It is almost 8 years now. As far as I remember or have known you, you haven't made any contribution to any forums from your OWN collection. All you do is either cut and paste from different websites and/or what other members upload, you download that stuff and then upload it in some other thread.

I remember many incidents like this. On RMIM groups you posted an article on Swaranlata which was written by me and copied it from website. Also there was another incident on RMIM, where you copied something from my website and kept on saying you have newspaper cutting of it and some esteemed member of RMIM proved it that you were lying. Also, Mahesh posted some Shamshad songs and you downloaded them and posted it in some other thread the SAME day without giving credit to the original contributor. I don't know why you do this but it makes you less trustworthy in other people eyes and people don't trust you anymore.

Anyways, coming back to the original topic. If your Mamu is that old, it might be possible that memories are playing hide and seek with him. Your only proof that Noor Jehan starred in those movies is that your Mamu said so... right?

I am willing to bet $100 infront of all members if you prove it to me that Noor Jehan (the actress-singer) starred in Abidah and Meera Bai. Long time ago, a rare interview was published in some newspaper in which W.Z. Ahmed discussed his films in detail and he said, the favorite film of his career was Meera Bai. There was NO Noor Jehan in that film.

If you think Noor Jehan starred in those films, show me a reasonable proof? Film Print, Picture or some article?

Thanks,

Ummer.

Hi Brother
You 10000000000 not right . I f i say i have from news paper cutting is right. 2nd I naver u/l song any members u/l others site, my mama is 92 year old what ever give news on any web site mama ji give.

before you ask me Noor jehan ji news, can you have any proof? Mr, M M BILOO Mehra is alive
hi is good father of Noorjehan , he and alder brother made panjabi movie from 1930 . after 1947 to 64 stay in pakistan ,than back to India. can tell me if she not act in movie ?? were name come from??
why all ways pakistan movie world show she work in movie. one time you told Noor jehan was in India & show her movie in Doordhrsan> that time no movie show in India,

HAVE proof she not work this move Abidah and Meera Bai??
how say I am not right, .

This web site have show movie name ask give reasonable proof????

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Noor-Jehan/25853919007?v=info

http://www.geocities.com/shahidfm2/noor_jehan.htm

http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/south-...n_10010010.html
dhall

This post has been edited by surhall: Oct 24 2009, 03:16 AM

[Ummer]

Hello Dhall Sahib,

I know you since the days of SKS yahoo groups. It is almost 8 years now. As far as I remember or have known you, you haven't made any contribution to any forums from your OWN collection. All you do is either cut and paste from different websites and/or what other members upload, you download that stuff and then upload it in some other thread.

I remember many incidents like this. On RMIM groups you posted an article on Swaranlata which was written by me and copied it from website. Also there was another incident on RMIM, where you copied something from my website and kept on saying you have newspaper cutting of it and some esteemed member of RMIM proved it that you were lying. Also, Mahesh posted some Shamshad songs and you downloaded them and posted it in some other thread the SAME day without giving credit to the original contributor. I don't know why you do this but it makes you less trustworthy in other people eyes and people don't trust you anymore.

Anyways, coming back to the original topic. If your Mamu is that old, it might be possible that memories are playing hide and seek with him. Your only proof that Noor Jehan starred in those movies is that your Mamu said so... right?

I am willing to bet $100 infront of all members if you prove it to me that Noor Jehan (the actress-singer) starred in Abidah and Meera Bai. Long time ago, a rare interview was published in some newspaper in which W.Z. Ahmed discussed his films in detail and he said, the favorite film of his career was Meera Bai. There was NO Noor Jehan in that film.

If you think Noor Jehan starred in those films, show me a reasonable proof? Film Print, Picture or some article?

Thanks,

Ummer.

Hi Brother
You 10000000000 not right . I f i say i have from news paper cutting is right. 2nd I naver u/l song any members u/l others site, my mama is 92 year old what ever give news on any web site mama ji give.

before you ask me Noor jehan ji news, can you have any proof? Mr, M M BILOO Mehra is alive
hi is good father of Noorjehan , he and alder brother made panjabi movie from 1930 . after 1947 to 64 stay in pakistan ,than back to India. can tell me if she not act in movie ?? were name come from??
why all ways pakistan movie world show she work in movie. one time you told Noor jehan was in India & show her movie in Doordhrsan> that time no movie show in India,

HAVE proof she not work this move Abidah and Meera Bai??
how say I am not right, .

This web site have show movie name ask give reasonable proof????

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Noor-Jehan/25853919007?v=info

http://www.geocities.com/shahidfm2/noor_jehan.htm

http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/south-...n_10010010.html
dhall

This further proves my point that you go to unknown/personal sites like geocities and cut and paste information from there. People like you + the people who create sites like those (without doing proper research) further complicates these matters. Anyone can write anything on the internet or on wikipedia, that is not a proof that Noor Jehan indeed acted in those films. As I said before, the name Noor Jehan appears as early as silent films and continues till 1968 in Hindi Films, thats is why it complicates her filmography.

If Noor Jehan indeed acted in Meera Bai and Abidah as you and your Mama claims... she must have sung songs in those films too.. Can you post the details of her songs from these films or upload songs? I need convincing proof that Noor Jehan indeed acted in those films. It will be a great news for all Noor Jehan fans... and there exists many more Noor Jehan songs.. Your only proof uptil now is your Mama and some personal websites... Then u bring in M.M. Billo Mehra... I have corresponded with his son, all he said was that his father might have directed some Pakistani films before migrating to India and he doesnt remember which ones, so he needed help with his father filmography in Pakistan. There was no dicussion of Abidah and Meera Bai...

I think it is against this board policy to search and dig previous posts for fighting purposes. But if you want I can go to RMIM and dig those posts.

[surhall]

Hello Dhall Sahib,

I know you since the days of SKS yahoo groups. It is almost 8 years now. As far as I remember or have known you, you haven't made any contribution to any forums from your OWN collection. All you do is either cut and paste from different websites and/or what other members upload, you download that stuff and then upload it in some other thread.

I remember many incidents like this. On RMIM groups you posted an article on Swaranlata which was written by me and copied it from website. Also there was another incident on RMIM, where you copied something from my website and kept on saying you have newspaper cutting of it and some esteemed member of RMIM proved it that you were lying. Also, Mahesh posted some Shamshad songs and you downloaded them and posted it in some other thread the SAME day without giving credit to the original contributor. I don't know why you do this but it makes you less trustworthy in other people eyes and people don't trust you anymore.

Anyways, coming back to the original topic. If your Mamu is that old, it might be possible that memories are playing hide and seek with him. Your only proof that Noor Jehan starred in those movies is that your Mamu said so... right?

I am willing to bet $100 infront of all members if you prove it to me that Noor Jehan (the actress-singer) starred in Abidah and Meera Bai. Long time ago, a rare interview was published in some newspaper in which W.Z. Ahmed discussed his films in detail and he said, the favorite film of his career was Meera Bai. There was NO Noor Jehan in that film.

If you think Noor Jehan starred in those films, show me a reasonable proof? Film Print, Picture or some article?

Thanks,

Ummer.

Hi Brother
You 10000000000 not right . I f i say i have from news paper cutting is right. 2nd I naver u/l song any members u/l others site, my mama is 92 year old what ever give news on any web site mama ji give.

before you ask me Noor jehan ji news, can you have any proof? Mr, M M BILOO Mehra is alive
hi is good father of Noorjehan , he and alder brother made panjabi movie from 1930 . after 1947 to 64 stay in pakistan ,than back to India. can tell me if she not act in movie ?? were name come from??
why all ways pakistan movie world show she work in movie. one time you told Noor jehan was in India & show her movie in Doordhrsan> that time no movie show in India,

HAVE proof she not work this move Abidah and Meera Bai??
how say I am not right, .

This web site have show movie name ask give reasonable proof????

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Noor-Jehan/25853919007?v=info

http://www.geocities.com/shahidfm2/noor_jehan.htm

http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/south-...n_10010010.html
dhall

This further proves my point that you go to unknown/personal sites like geocities and cut and paste information from there. People like you + the people who create sites like those (without doing proper research) further complicates these matters. Anyone can write anything on the internet or on wikipedia, that is not a proof that Noor Jehan indeed acted in those films. As I said before, the name Noor Jehan appears as early as silent films and continues till 1968 in Hindi Films, thats is why it complicates her filmography.

If Noor Jehan indeed acted in Meera Bai and Abidah as you and your Mama claims... she must have sung songs in those films too.. Can you post the details of her songs from these films or upload songs? I need convincing proof that Noor Jehan indeed acted in those films. It will be a great news for all Noor Jehan fans... and there exists many more Noor Jehan songs.. Your only proof uptil now is your Mama and some personal websites... Then u bring in M.M. Billo Mehra... I have corresponded with his son, all he said was that his father might have directed some Pakistani films before migrating to India and he doesnt remember which ones, so he needed help with his father filmography in Pakistan. There was no dicussion of Abidah and Meera Bai...

I think it is against this board policy to search and dig previous posts for fighting purposes. But if you want I can go to RMIM and dig those posts.

HI

What you do same take news put on site.
give my awwnser as per list she work in this movie. --what you have reasonable proof she not work

what ever you u/l song take from web site . you go on RMIM ask this right or ???
2 nd i meet 1996 MR, BILOO MEHRA ji his home. he told we give panjabi movie to her,he his brother made many hindi movie 1930 to 1970 ,
dhall