Sahir Ludhianvi's Filmography, Mere Geet Tumhaare Hain!!! Options Rating

[Anupama]

Radha Krishna 1954
Tum Bansi Ho Main Taan - Lata Mangeshkar & Geeta Dutt

I don't hear Geeta Dutt's voice in this song that CM2 uploaded.
What do mahesh ji and parag think?

Rajnishji, I do hear Geetaji's voice in the lines - Tan Do Hain Ik Hai Pran, Jug Jug Se Bhes Badalte.......


Geeta Dutt's name is mentioned in Gulshan Pammer's Sahir Ludhianvi's Geet-Kosh too which was compiled with the help of Shri Harminder Singh Humraz.

I am attaching the scan.



Parag, we need you here.

[Anupama]

FOR LADIES ONLY (TITLEE)(1951) too isn't by Sahir!
Anupamaji, could you please share the excel list in zip format?

Erumji, as per my gathered info, Sahir has written the lyrics of three songs for the movie For Ladies Only (Titli). Kindly recheck it!
I'll upload the excel sheet soon!

Anupamaji, thanks for excelsheet!

According to Hindi Film geet Kosh, "Hum Toh LOVE Karke Pachhtaaya" & "Yeh Nayi Roshni Aayi Hai" are written by "SOHANLAL SAAHIR" and "Mera Mann Jhoom Jhoom Lehraaye" is by SEHRAAI"

Erumji, thanks a lot for checking it again for me. Now who is this Sohanlal Sahir?
Mere 3 Sahir ke songs kam ho gaye
I've updated my excel sheet accordingly. Thanks!

[parag_sankla]

I am listening to it as I am writting this line. There is a second female voice but I am not 100% sure if it is Geeta ji or not. May be the audio file I have has some problem

Regards
Parag

[parag_sankla]

But, Mahesh has confirmed that this is a duet of Lata ji and Geeta ji here

http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?s=&a...st&p=537046

So I stand corrected

[Anupama]

I am listening to it as I am writting this line. There is a second female voice but I am not 100% sure if it is Geeta ji or not. May be the audio file I have has some problem

Regards
Parag

Maheshji might be able to shed some light on this.

[Anupama]

But, Mahesh has confirmed that this is a duet of Lata ji and Geeta ji here

http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?s=&a...st&p=537046

So I stand corrected

Let's wait for MaheshKSji too.

[r&d]

At first I thought that Lataji's voice was correct
but if I slow the track and change the pitch
I guess I can hear Geetaji's voice and Lataji's voice
sounds like yasmin songs.


Another possibility is that there is third voice and
that is Geeta Dutt who only sings there lines.

.
.
.

Tu meri roop kahani
mein teri prem katha hoon

.
.
.
dhara ka roop hai sagar
sagar ka roop hai dhara



This post has been edited by r&d: Nov 8 2008, 01:26 PM

[Akshay Manwani]

Anupama ji,

I am doing some research work on Sahir saab?

Can you please send me Sahir's filmography file which you had created in xl?

Thanks,

Akshay

At first I thought that Lataji's voice was correct
but if I slow the track and change the pitch
I guess I can hear Geetaji's voice and Lataji's voice
sounds like yasmin songs.


Another possibility is that there is third voice and
that is Geeta Dutt who only sings there lines.

.
.
.

Tu meri roop kahani
mein teri prem katha hoon

.
.
.
dhara ka roop hai sagar
sagar ka roop hai dhara

[Anupama]

Akshayji, I will surely send the list to you when you provide me with your email address. I'm excited to know that you're doing some research on Sahir sahab.

[parag_sankla]

Which is the first film of Sahir sahab as a lyricist?

Thanks in advance

Regards
Parag

[HumTum]

Which is the first film of Sahir sahab as a lyricist?

Thanks in advance

Regards
Parag

I think it is Azaadi ke raha par (1949).

[parag_sankla]

HT bhai

As per Upperstall, it is Naujawan (1951).

http://www.upperstall.com/people/sahir-ludhianvi

But, as per Wiki, you are right

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahir_Ludhianvi

I was thinking it is Baazi (1951)

Anu, can you please confirm this?

Regards
Parag

This post has been edited by parag_sankla: Oct 23 2009, 08:22 PM

[HumTum]

Quoting from Wiki -

Sahir Ludhianvi made his debut in films writing lyrics for the film Aazadi Ki Raah Par (1949). The film had four songs written by him and his first song was Badal Rahi Hai Zindagi.... Both the film and its songs went unnoticed. However, with Naujawaan (1951), he gained recognition. S.D. Burman composed the music for Naujawaan. Even today, the film's lilting song, ठंडी हवाए लहराके आए..., remains popular. His first major success came the same year with Guru Dutt's directorial debut, Baazi (1951), again pairing him with music composer, S.D. Burman. Thus he became, part of the Guru Dutt team, and after the success of Naujawaan and Baazi, the combination of Sahir Ludhianvi and S.D. Burman came out with many more everlasting songs.

[r&d]

Quoting from Wiki -

Sahir Ludhianvi made his debut in films writing lyrics for the film Aazadi Ki Raah Par (1949). The film had four songs written by him and his first song was Badal Rahi Hai Zindagi.... Both the film and its songs went unnoticed. However, with Naujawaan (1951), he gained recognition. S.D. Burman composed the music for Naujawaan. Even today, the film's lilting song, ठंडी हवाए लहराके आए..., remains popular. His first major success came the same year with Guru Dutt's directorial debut, Baazi (1951), again pairing him with music composer, S.D. Burman. Thus he became, part of the Guru Dutt team, and after the success of Naujawaan and Baazi, the combination of Sahir Ludhianvi and S.D. Burman came out with many more everlasting songs.

any chance the songs are available.
http://www.earthmusic.net/hindi-film-songs...adi+Ki+Raah+Par

I only have the G. M. Durrani's song.

[Exon]

Quoting from Wiki -

Sahir Ludhianvi made his debut in films writing lyrics for the film Aazadi Ki Raah Par (1949). The film had four songs written by him and his first song was Badal Rahi Hai Zindagi.... Both the film and its songs went unnoticed. However, with Naujawaan (1951), he gained recognition. S.D. Burman composed the music for Naujawaan. Even today, the film's lilting song, ठंडी हवाए लहराके आए..., remains popular. His first major success came the same year with Guru Dutt's directorial debut, Baazi (1951), again pairing him with music composer, S.D. Burman. Thus he became, part of the Guru Dutt team, and after the success of Naujawaan and Baazi, the combination of Sahir Ludhianvi and S.D. Burman came out with many more everlasting songs.

any chance the songs are available.
http://www.earthmusic.net/hindi-film-songs...adi+Ki+Raah+Par

I only have the G. M. Durrani's song.

A few days ago, Erum had opened a thread for this rare album.
http://www.hamaraforums.com/index.php?s=&a...st&p=633584

So far, only one song has appeared in that thread.

Exon