Do You Know Any Pair Of Almost Identically Tuned Songs Of Rafi Saab?

Venkatji, here are the songs

Film - Baap Bete 1959
MD - Madan Mohan
Lyricist - Rajendra Krishan
3:45/160kbps

Bol Bol Bol My Little Dove



Film - Dil De Ke Dekho 1959
MD - Usha Khanna
Lyricist - Majrooh Sultanpuri
3:13/160kbps

Kaun Yeh Aaya Mehfil Mein


And

here is the link for Paul Anka's Diana

http://www.sendspace.com/file/g33e9t

Venkatji, I leave upto you for the critical analysis. To me they are almost the same. Just a bit here n there.

So far, this is the list of identically tuned pairs of Rafi songs.

Pair 1

1. "Ek Chameli Ki Mandwe Tale"--Film: Cha Cha Cha(1964)---MD:Iqbal Quereshi--Rafi and Asha

2. "Aaj Mausam Ki Masti Mein Gaaye Pawan"--Film:Banarasi Thug(1962)---MD:Iqbal Quereshi---Rafi and Lata

Pair 2---This is actually a Triplet!

1. "Tu Hind Bane Ya na Musalmaan Banega, Insaan Ki Aulad"---Film:Dhool Ka Phool(1959)---MD:N.Datta---Rafi

2. "Kya Kya Na Sitam Tujh Pe Huve Mehlon Ki Raani"---Film:Mohini(1957)---MD:N.Datta---Rafi

3. "Gham Hon Ke Sitam Tu Kabhi Aansoo Na Bahana"--MOVIE : NAI MAA (1960)--MUSIC : RAVI--Rafi

Pair 3

1. "Main Kal Phir Milungi"--Film:Dr.Vidya(1962)--MD:SDB--Rafi & Lata

2. "Kisi Ki Mohabbat Mein"--Film:Kaise Kahoon(1964)--MD:SDB--Rafi & Asha


Pair 4

1. "Parwadigarey Aalam Tera Hi Hai Sahara....Film: Haatim Tai(1956)--MD:S.N.Tripathi--Rafi

2. "Choota Watan Hamara ,Hafiz Khuda Tumhara...Film:Khuda Ka Banda(1957)--MD:S.N.Tripathi--Rafi

Pair 5

1."Agar Milgayi Mujhko, Rah-e-Madina, Mohammed Ke Nakshe"--Islamic devotional--Rafi

2. "Unhe Qissa-e-Gham"--Non-Filmi--Rafi

Pair 6

1. "Hue Hum Jin Ke Liye Barbaad"--Film:Deedar(1951)--MD:Naushad--Rafi

2. "Basi Hai Dil Mein Nabi Ki Yaad"--Islamic Naat--Rafi

Pair 7

1. "Har Bekass Ke GhamKhaar Ho Tum"--Islamic Devotional--Md:Khayyam--Rafi

2. "Mere Geeton Ka Singhaar Ho Tum"--Non-Filmi--MD:Khayyam--Rafi

Pair 8

1. "Pyar Ke Sagar Se Nikli--Ek Jhoot Hai Jis Ka Duniya Ne"--Film:Jadoo(1951)--MD:Naushad--Rafi

2. "Jab Se Nabi Aankhon Mein--Yeh Haal Hai Mera Kursat Mein" --Islamic Devotional-Rafi

Pair 9

1."So Ja Sanam Teri Jawan Palkon Tale"--Film:Rocky Mera Naam(1973)--MD:Sapan Jagmohan--Rafi

2. "Pyaar Lage Raat Aur Din Ka Yeh Milan Pyar Ki"--Film:Habari(1979)--MD:Sapan Jagmohan--Rafi & Sulakshana Pandit

Pair 10

1. "Bol Bol Bol My Little Dove"---Film:Baap Bete(1959)---MD:Madan Mohan--Rafi

2. "Kaun Yeh Aaya Mehfil Mein"---Film:Dil Deke Dekho(1959)--MD:Usha Khanna---Rafi & Asha



More later.



Venkat

Anu Ji, Aap Bole Aur Galti Ho, Aisa Ho Hi Nahin Sakta.

Both the songs are almost identical both on Mukhda and Antara. Mukhdas are identical and Antaras are almost identical.

Including the "Aa Aa Aa Aa/ La La La La" in the Antara of Baap Bete song and its match, "Oho Oho Oho Ohohoho", in the Antara of Dil Deke Dekkho song!!! One song is on Neeta and the other on Sheela.

Very good find. More so because, unlike the earlier nine, the songs in this pair have different MDs!!!

So, we have the 10th identical pair. Yahoooo.


Venkat

Here is the updated list of ten identical pairs (both on Mukhda and Antara) of Rafi Saab's songs.

Venkat

Anu Ji,

I have now downloaded that Paul Anka's DIANA too and heard it.

Neeta and Sheela have come in place of Diana!!!

Usha Khanna has copied it 'makhi ki makhhi', whereas Madan Mohan Saab has tried to somewhat improvise!!!

Venkat

PS. One naughty question, though.

Did MM and UK copy Diana without each other's knowledge and find that both copied the same song, only after both songs were released?

Or, did either of them (ie. either MM or UK) copy the other's song? After all, both songs are of 1959.

Venkat

Anu Ji, Aap Bole Aur Galti Ho, Aisa Ho Hi Nahin Sakta.

Both the songs are almost identical both on Mukhda and Antara. Mukhdas are identical and Antaras are almost identical.

Including the "Aa Aa Aa Aa/ La La La La" in the Antara of Baap Bete song and its match, "Oho Oho Oho Ohohoho", in the Antara of Dil Deke Dekkho song!!! One song is on Neeta and the other on Sheela.

Very good find. More so because, unlike the earlier nine, the songs in this pair have different MDs!!!

So, we have the 10th identical pair. Yahoooo.


Venkat

Any other ideas?

Venkat

Here is the updated list of ten identical pairs (both on Mukhda and Antara) of Rafi Saab's songs.

Venkat

One small correction Venkatji - Unhein Kissa-e-Gham Likhne Jo Baithe is from Naya Kanoon 1965.
MD - Madan Mohan
Lyricist - Hasrat Jaipuri

Bhangra (1958) - Jatt Kudiyaan To'n Darda Maara - Rafi Sahab & Shamshad Begum (Punjabi)
MD - Hansraj Behl
Lyricist - Verma Malik
6:25/160kbps



Reporter Raju (1962) - Mujhe Dekh Na Kudiye Mud Ke - Rafi Sahab & Asha Bhonsle
MD - S.Mohinder
Lyricist - Anjaan
5:09/160kbps

Venkat-ji,

These two songs sound similar in both Mukhda and Antara:

Tang Aa Chuke Hai (Pyaasa/1957/SDB)

AND

Humko Tumhare Ishq Ne (Ek Musafir Ek Haseena/1962/OPN)


The former has no music, whereas the latter has the tabla and harmonium.

Could OPN have been inspired by SDB, or is this tune from another source ?.